They're one of the most iconic alt-rock bands of all time, but that doesn't make it any easier when it comes to whittling Pixies' extensive back catalogue down to just five songs.
However, we've had a go below, ahead of their gig at the Iveagh Gardens this Thursday.
Are you a Kim Deal fan, and does that colour your opinion? Do you prefer the early stuff? What should we have left out? What should we have kept in? Should we have included something from 'Trompe Le Monde'?
Do let us know if you feel that strongly about it...
2. 'WAVE OF MUTILATION'
4. 'WHERE IS MY MIND?'