The Guys Next Door is an intimate portrait of a real "Modern Family." Meet Erik and Sandro, a gay married couple whose friend Rachel is a surrogate for their two daughters. Rachel, who is in her 40s, is married to Tony and they have three children. Together, they all form a unique extended family. Spanning three years, this lyrical documentary tackles some of the most pertinent issues of our time - gay marriage and parenting, surrogacy as a path to having children, and the extension and redefinition of what it means to be "an American family."