David, a handsome gay urban professional, thinks he might be having a midlife crisis, so he decides to hold a different kind of weekend pool party at his West Hollywood home. He wants to see if there really is a match with one of his former boyfriends and invites them all over to see if there really is a husband for him somewhere in his pool. Soon the weekend evolves into a whirlpool of nosey neighbors, pressuring parents, stubborn siblings, and sexy pizza boys.