Viewer Reviews

Viewer Reviews of MILK

Milk rating: 4 Star
Unbelievable prefromance from Penn - Sarah

To make a biopic of someone is probably extremely difficult, but to make one about a person who was so influential and inspiring and who lived in the recent past must be nearly impossible. Not only does the film have to portray the time authentically but also the people who lived in it. Harvey Milk was a one in a million, who inspired hope in gay people more ...


Milk rating: 4 Star
Good, though depends on your mindset - Cyberx_94

Milk Milk is a political biographical Drama about Harvey Milk , the real life politician and civil rights activist who became the first homosexual man to take office in America. The movie stars Sean Penn in the lead role and is directed by Gus von Gant. It is 2 hours long. See this film immediately. I cannot stress that enough. Though do so with an open more ...


Milk rating: 4 Star
A must see movie - carol

This is a fantastic movie and teaches alot about what people had to go through, which still goes on today but Harvey fought for justice for all and I support too. It was a sad ending. But atleast we know he'll never be forgotten. Great movie. more ...


Milk rating: 5 Star
Phenomenal film - simonconnolly

Milk is based on the true life battle of Harvey Milk who fought to prevent discrimination against the gays in California for years. On his 40th birthday Harvey decides to do more with his life and so he runs for office in the hope of becoming the first openly gay man to be elected into office. In his first year he is faced with a sever lack of support and a more ...


Milk rating: 4 Star
Excellent - jennith

Harvey Milk was the first openly gay man to hold senior public office in the Unites States, becoming one of San Francisco's City Supervisors in 1977. In 1978, he, along with the city's mayor, George Moscone, was shot dead by Dan White, a former supervisor who had resigned his post and then sought to be reinstated. Milk's story will be new to many on this more ...


Milk rating: 4 Star
Deeply Satisfying - Shari

It takes a lot for any film to penetrate my icy cold heart, but this one had me on the verge of possibly having a lump in my throat. Milk tells the story of Harvey Milk, who at the age of 47 became the first openly gay person to be elected to office in the United States, only to be assassinated within his first year as city supervisor. Milk is played with more ...


Milk rating: 4 Star
Excellent - Bunny Summers

Great film, Sean Penn is really good, James Franco is fabulous. Their characters' relationship very well portrayed. It's well worth a visit to the Cinema. Not sure if the rating is really 15A - would have thought it more 16. Having said that, I assume over 15s will only bring mature under 15s to see it - it is NOT a kids film. Enjoy. more ...


Milk rating: 3 Star
Admirable but empty - Janet

Let me start by saying I love Sean Penn but I do not buy him as a gay man. Maybe he is typecast for me. I ended up comparing him to Philip Seymour Hoffman in Capone and he did not stack up well. Milk tells the story of Harvey Milk who was the first gay person to be elected to public office in the States and it is a wonderful story of hope. I am glad that it more ...


Milk rating: 4 Star
Well Worth a Watch - Keith C

Good solid movie, with some excellent performances from all involved. Sean Penn is excellent and a big change from the dark, edgy character he normally portrays. Josh Brolin is excellent as ever and you can sense the conflict his character goes through from the off. Real Life news clips give this a real sense of authenticity and you leave feeling you've more ...


Milk rating: 1 Star
GONE OFF MILK ! - Keith

Milk tells the story of Harvey Milk, the first openly gay politician elected in the US. The film should have been called 'Campaign' because that's all it was about. Harvey Milk's character, his life, his past, his weaknesses etc were never explored, he was portrayed as this kindly human who exceeds anyone's version of a saint. I would of liked to see a more more ...


Milk rating: 5 Star
Very good movie - nicenic

I just came from the movie and it was avery good movie. I didnt know who was MIlk so i thought lets watch it and it is great to see the actors actually kissing for more than one second like a very intimate kiss. Also I like the mix between the film and original films use to show San Fran in the 70s. As I didnt read anything about the movie I didn't expect more ...


Milk rating: 4 Star
Milk delivers a universal message - Madz

Forget about Oscar nominations and pseudo-antagonism between Sean Penn and Mickey Rourke. Had Milk been released at any other time during the year it would be no less remarkable. But the fact of the matter is that Mr Penn is unable to give anything but Oscar-worthy performances and his portrayal of Harvey Milk is nothing short of spectacular. (Yes, I'm a more ...


Milk rating: 5 Star
Top Drawer - Brian

I went into 'Milk' open minded. Knowing that it was a film worthy of Oscars, and with a exceedingly talented young cast; I was expecting for the film to be something special, and I wasn't disappointed. 'Milk' tells the true story of Harvey Milk, a gay politician fighting for equality in a troubled San Francisco. The film is told almost as a final memoir, more ...


Milk rating: 4 Star
A true revolutionary - Siobhan L

This is a great movie - well shot that tells a story well. Penn does a great job as this social revolutionary. The inclusion of actual newsreel helps tell the story of Harveys political life in San Francisco. It reminds us that until very recently all homosexuals were in the closet. Harveys relationship is the second story that is told well - not just a gay more ...


Milk rating: 3 Star
another biopic but still good - tom

while this is a very well made film with the relevent subject matter handled with care i still feel itsjust another standard biopic we've seen a hundred times before. The highs and lows of some great figure it's been done. It seems every year coming up to the oscars there's at least a couple of biopics, this years are Che and Milk. It's a good film and sean more ...


Milk rating: 3 Star
very good - tom

milk is a great movie it handle's subject matter with care and of course sean penn is great in the role. My only problem with this film is the whole standard biopic the highs and lows of some great real life indivdual its be done a hundred times before but this is still and exceptionally film and penn fully deserves his oscar nom (heres hoping rourke will more ...


Milk rating: 4 Star
Brilliant - Craig

Sean Penn proves yet again why he is one of the greatest actors gracing our screens. 'Milk' is a fantastic story and this movie defines both the career of Harvey Milk and the plight of all homosexuals in America during the 70's. The prejudices they faced and the battles they fought to earn their place in history and Harvey Milk was a great friend, role more ...


Milk rating: 5 Star
Great Actors give justice to a Great Story - Shane

30 years on and the issues told in this story are still relevant today. The casting is perfect and the similarity between the actors and those they are playing is amazing. The story is told with power and shows how one person can influence the masses. Milk may have been standing up for the gay community, however he gained the support of the Unions and more ...


Milk rating: 4 Star
highly recommended - josuv22

milk tell the story of Harvey milk an openly gay man who fought and failed several time to become elected to the San Francisco Board of Supervisors, becoming the first openly gay man to be voted into public office in America. doing so he won a major victory for human rights at a time where laws were being proposed which were aimed to strongly discriminate more ...


Top Viewer Rated Movies

# Movie Average Rating
1This Is ItThis Is It rating: 4.5 Star
2The Twilight Saga: New MoonThe Twilight Saga: New Moon rating: 4 Star
3AvatarAvatar rating: 4 Star
4The Dark KnightThe Dark Knight rating: 4 Star
5Iron ManIron Man rating: 4 Star
6The HangoverThe Hangover rating: 4 Star
7The Twilight Saga: EclipseThe Twilight Saga: Eclipse rating: 4 Star
8Slumdog MillionaireSlumdog Millionaire rating: 4 Star
9Star TrekStar Trek rating: 4 Star
10Gone Baby GoneGone Baby Gone rating: 4 Star

Top Viewer Rated Albums

# Album Average Rating
1Florence and The Machine - LungsFlorence and The Machine - Lungs rating: 4.5 Star
2Lady GaGa - The FameLady GaGa - The Fame rating: 4 Star
3New Kids On the Block - The BlockNew Kids On the Block - The Block rating: 4 Star
4Taylor Swift - FearlessTaylor Swift - Fearless rating: 4 Star
5The Script - The ScriptThe Script - The Script rating: 3.5 Star
6Kings of Leon - Only By the NightKings of Leon - Only By the Night rating: 3.5 Star
7Metallica - Death MagneticMetallica - Death Magnetic rating: 3.5 Star
8Coldplay - Viva la Vida or Death and All His FriendsColdplay - Viva la Vida or Death and All His Friends rating: 3.5 Star
9McFly - Radio:ACTIVEMcFly - Radio:ACTIVE rating: 3.5 Star
10Cascada - Perfect DayCascada - Perfect Day rating: 3.5 Star

League Table

# Viewer Points Reviews
1Eoghan Bolger2665328
2Simon Connolly2460282
3jennith1933361
4pandabat1650205
5mart1n1574261
6HSP1266135
7Siobhan L852211
8Sarah751151
9Hanley60689
10Cascarino54175
11Plant52996
12Gary45478
13spikeprint45169
14norm40752
15Superpaul40359
16MicealJ39848
17Shari37044
18Aine35443
19Keith C34465
20aidanlucid34240
21Colm230532143
22reme30534
23andrewire30340
24Keith R29332
25fredgarven28433
26Fiona7427435
27Hermiepoohbear27261
28markwalsh26838
29Bunny Starr26243
30Sam24039
31Slick23846
32hellcat198323438
33scorpio622838
34Bobbi Jones22125
35Jason O Mahony22026
36will459222024
37Deli21860
38Steven Seagull21422
39stonecold21241
40declanh20626
41Lorraine20527
42Patrick McLaren20525
43amy20529
44AaronQuinn20453
45dervalmccormack20223
46richeyc200019829
47HHhhhmmmm....18827
48ging-grr18732
49Kankan18438
50A18032