If you scare easy, you should probably never go on The Ellen Show, because she does this a lot.

The latest guests on the talk show were Avengers: Infinity War stars Chris Hemsworth and Benedict Cumberbatch, the latter of whom talked about his new series Patrick Melrose as well as about the superhero epic that Marvel fans have been waiting for.

While discussing what’s next for the actor, Ellen asked about the potential of Cumberbatch starring in a horror film, since he hasn’t done one before, to which Cumberbatch replied he was interested, mentioning at one point that he scares easily.

Little did he know the surprise Ellen had in store for him…