The Thing (2011)
Starring: Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje, Eric Christian Olsen, Joel Edgerton, Mary Elizabeth Winstead
Details: US/102mins 16
Mary Elizabeth Winstead is smart grad student, Kate, who is approached by Ulrich Thomsen's mysterious Dr. Sander Halvorson when an alien spacecraft is discovered near an Antarctic research site. Removing the creature from the ice, it soon wakes and chows down on one miscellaneous crew member and wreaks havoc on the base. Being so far from even a hint of civilisation, Kate and rugged helicopter pilot Carter (a typically watchable Joel Edgerton) attempt to keep their wits about them and stay alive. Not easy when you have a giant hungry mouth running around the place, devouring/mimicking folk. That indigestion must be horrific.
Somewhat unfairly slated by American critics, there's actually a fair bit of detail gone in to making this slick looking production work as a prequel. Granted, while the Carpenter flick was staggeringly innovative, as a direct link to that film, this newbie was never going to achieve the same effect - a template had already been set. While it also lacks on the tension front, it still works well as a companion piece - actually complementing its world.
Of course there are problems, and this hasn't been sitting on the shelf for over year for no reason. The supporting characters are never given enough meat to register and you can almost pick which ones are going to be picked off in order. That naturally causes proceedings to lack tension - something that was huge part of why its predecessor worked. Thomsen's portrayal of Halvorson also has a touch of pantomime about it; he's a little too obvious early on, and you've seen this type of driven-at-all-costs character too many times before. At one point you expect him to have a hook for a hand and an eye patch.
Solid work from Winstead and Edgerton, and some genuinely disgusting moments should keep genre fans entertained. Just don't expect Carpenter's classic to be rivalled.
Review by Mike Sheridan
Your Comments
Tyler Durden
If they make a sequel, will they call it "The Things", or "Another Thing"? And if they then make a sequel to "Another Thing" I propose "And Another Thing" as the title :)
Posted 02/12/2011 12:10:40
FilmBuff76
Being a huge fan of John Carpenter's 1982 masterpiece (itself a remake), I've had my critical knives sharpened since I first saw the awfully familiar trailer for this new Thing. Carpenter's film is one of the most perfect horror films, so it was going to be a tough act to beat. The new Thing is both a prequel and a remake of Carpenter's film or, as the filmmakers suggest, it shares the same DNA. The Cold War-era paranoia and distrust is mostly thrown out in favour of extensive CGI creature effects which unfortunately aren't as convincing as Rob Bottin's grotesque beauty. Most characters are thinly sketched and the film riffs on several scenes in Carpenter's film without any real impact (e.g. the laughable tooth test scene). It's amusing to think of a film that copies another film, just like the thing itself. The closing credits join the dots to Carpenter's film but in a rather lazy fashion. But yet... the film isn't a complete disaster and remains solidly watchable. I really wanted to hate it but I got swept along by the story and have to admit to being mildly surprised by it. Sure, it's nowhere near as good as Carpenter's film but it just about scrapes by.
Posted 02/12/2011 21:48:28
Tyler Durden
Watched it earlier, an excellent addition to the "Thing" legacy. This version ain't a patch on Carpenter's classic, but it's a damn good attempt. The pacing, fx, and tension are all superb, perhaps the only thing (no pun intended) missing is some true originality. Loved the ending\tie-in to the '82 version. Worth seeing.
Posted 03/12/2011 22:55:39
Login or Register to leave a comment
Disclaimer
The opinions expressed here are those of the viewer and do not reflect those of Entertainment.ie. Entertainment.ie accepts no responsibility, legal or otherwise, for their accuracy of content. Please contact us to report abusive content
Search for Cinema Listings
Most Popular Reviews
|
|
Men in Black III |
|
|
Moonrise Kingdom |
|
|
The Raid |
|
|
Cosmopolis |
|
|
Dark Shadows |




