Your Comments

Bryce

Decent intelligent movies are a rarity these days. I'm looking forward to this.

Posted 12/01/2012 11:05:09

 

FilmBuff76

Is Clint Eastwood having another senior moment? After the mediocre Hereafter, we're now presented with an only slightly-better effort with J. Edgar. There's no denying that J. Edgar Hoover was a powerful figure in 20th Century American history, but this stodgy, leaden film doesn't really do him justice. It bears more than a few similarities to The Iron Lady, another recent disappointment. The script by Milk's Dustin Lance Black is reasonably good but is let down by dubious production values. Given that the film spans half a century, the old-age make-up is unconvincing. Armie Hammer, as Hoover's right-hand man and apparent lover, looks like he's a 200-year-old zombie at times. As always Leonardo DiCaprio is superb, but even acting through all that make-up doesn't quite feel right. Why not cast an older actor to be play Hoover in his later years? By the end, it ultimately feels lifeless and flat, but just about scrapes by on the strength of DiCaprio's performance.

Posted 21/01/2012 18:50:19

 

Andy Millea

Excellent character study and great looking period piece with a very good performance from Di Caprio. Clint is one of the best directors today making films for an intelligent adult audience, 4/5.

Posted 04/02/2012 18:05:28

 

Login or Register to leave a comment

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed here are those of the viewer and do not reflect those of Entertainment.ie. Entertainment.ie accepts no responsibility, legal or otherwise, for their accuracy of content. Please contact us to report abusive content

Search for Cinema Listings

Most Popular Reviews

Men in Black III rated 2
What To Expect When You're Expecting rated 3
The Raid rated 4.5
The Dictator rated 4
Marvel Avengers Assemble rated 4.5

Your Reviews...

 rated 3

Interesting, but ultimately too unfocused - Simon Connolly

J Edgar is the story of J Edgar Hoover, the man who was the first director of the Bureau of Investigation and who went... MORE21/03/2012 00:48:20
 rated 3

A great character study - Eoghan Bolger

J Edgar J Edgar is a drama film by Clint Eastwood, it stars Judy Dent and Leonardo Decaprio, is 140 minutes long and... MORE21/01/2012 23:37:32
 rated 2

Seen a preview last night,wish I'd of stayed at home - mart1n

I think something's in certain movies really stand out and here it's the make up. With de caprio playing j what Hoover... MORE19/01/2012 10:26:09
Seen a film that you just can't stop talking about? Write a review and tell us!