P.S., I Love You
P.S I Love you. - filmfilm
Loved the book and loved the story but the film butchered the book completely. The story line was different lot of scenes missing also. If you liked the book try to keep an open mind when going to see the film because you will be disappointed. i cried alot in this film but i was referring back to the book the whole film. dodgy accents aswel.
Review published on the 10 January 2008 09:19
Disclaimer
The opinions expressed here are those of the viewer and do not reflect those of Entertainment.ie. Entertainment.ie accepts no responsibility, legal or otherwise, for their accuracy of content. Please contact us to report abusive content
More uLike Viewer Reviews
LOVED IT - Pink Pizza
OMG i love this film the actors performed it soo wrong so whoever said it was rubbish they need there head examined by a vet cause it was a bit of everything oit was romantic, comedy and tragidy what... MORE
16 January 2010 11:48
why oh why......?? - mgalvin25
Why did they make this film,why don't they get Irish actors to play Irish parts,why is it nigh impossible to make a good romantic comedy?? This film ticks every cliche in the book and more besides. I... MORE
14 January 2009 21:19
P.S., Don't Watch This - jimmyendless
So, P.S., I Love You. Adapted from the book I haven't read, I can't make any comparisons between the two and the tweaking that took place in order to make it appeal to a greater audience, but from... MORE
06 November 2008 13:14
This film makes me cringe - me
My god this film is AWFUL. I loved the book and the film well and truly killed everything good the book had going. The acting is brutal and the story has been changed far too much, most of all - the... MORE
03 November 2008 16:51
fantabulously sweet!!!!!! - crystal004
Its a damn sweet and a very beautiful movie!!!!!!!!! i dnt knw bout the book bt the movie was enough fr me i ve seen it more than a half century !!!!! god i loved it!!!! MORE
02 November 2008 13:10
P.S I Love You - Katie
One Word-Bad. I must admit that I didn't enjoy the book so I had quite low expectations when going to see the movie. I had only one thought-it couldn't be worse than the book. But it was!! The Irish... MORE
24 September 2008 20:06
hi - Aram A A
THIS IS THE BEST FILM IVE SEEN ALL YEAR. DEFO JUS FOR THE GIRLS, IT WUD BRING A TEAR EVEN TO THE HARDEST OF EYES... The best The best The best The best The best The best The best The best MORE
12 April 2008 13:36
PS I Love You - I Loved It!! - Niamh
This is great chick flick. Although it doesn't follow the stroy line in the book, it is a lovely adaptation which all romantics out there will appreciate. it had me in stitches with laughter and in... MORE
06 April 2008 12:02
Very boring - Maeve
When i was watchin p.s i love you on the cinema about half way through during one of the boring scenes a man in the row next to me fell asleep and started snoring, it was i very boring movie there... MORE
26 March 2008 18:50
Best chick Flik out there! - Someone in love
Obviously the people that rate this movie poorly have never had someone truely love them....and loved them back.... MORE
18 March 2008 05:00
ps i luv - elaine
omg i am upsessed wit dis film i can not stop listen ta da galway grl omg i cryed mi eeyes out wit dis film nd i luk it up on youtube nd alkso start crin its sadded movie eva nd i cnt wait until its... MORE
08 March 2008 16:25
let down - Erica
When I heard they were making a movie of this I was looking forward to seeing it but it was a complete let down. And the accents pleeeeeassse. MORE
21 February 2008 20:17
The Galway Girl - Johnny Dangerously
Never saw Hillary Swank (Or Hillary's Wank as my friend calls her) in a girly-baby role, something about our little Million-Dollar Baby that just doesn't say 'Shower me in pink and let's go shopping'... MORE
17 February 2008 01:32
I think it was ok - mimo
I read the book before i watched the movie and think that the book is way better then the movie coz the movie had alot of extr stuff and there was alot important stuff were taken from the movie... MORE
15 February 2008 19:25
PS I loved it - clogherheadchic
great chick flick with possibly the worst irish accents i've heard in a long while.good movie to have a laugh and a cry at.real mixed bag of emotions. MORE
13 February 2008 15:34
lauren and sophie think gerardbutler is gorgues - lauren and sophie think gerardbutler is gorgues
we thort the film was the best film ever because it had gerard butler in i would watch it a million times hes so dreamy i would make love4 to him a 3sum lol hahahahahahahaha xx MORE
13 February 2008 13:46
great - me
it is a great love movie with comdy loved it it is well worth seeing MORE
12 February 2008 20:33
Feel Good Movie - trishastar
Loved it, it was easy going, funny, sad - a movie with everything - Definitely one for the girls only though!!!! MORE
07 February 2008 11:21
P.S i love you. - Jason
I thought this was a great flim, even no the accent wasn't to good. Still enjoyed it. MORE
06 February 2008 09:55
What an accent???? - Sue
Totaly disappointed with the pathetic accent. Not at all like the original book, seems like they tried way to hard on this one. MORE
05 February 2008 11:00
PS This is Poo - rob
I secretly wanted to see this, I 'complained' like mad on the way in of course and extracted promises of going to see a proper manly movie in return for my sacrifice. It started off ok in fairness to... MORE
04 February 2008 22:24
hi - cool dude
this film is not great! kinda date-ish! i wudnt watch it again! MORE
03 February 2008 12:59
makes u laugh and cri!! - anonymous
i loved ps i love you it made me laugh and cry i went to see it with my friends normally we go to the cinema and mess and talk but this one we couldnt mess or talk we had to watch it!!!!! i loved it:) MORE
03 February 2008 12:57
PS I Love You - Jedi's Light Sabre
I am not a girlie girl, but I have to say I really enjoyed this movie. Ok the Irish accents were complete rubbish, however, the eye candy was very easy on the ole eyes!! Few funny bits in it and a... MORE
31 January 2008 15:12
Bring a box of tissues!!!! - J S
After reading the reviews I thought this film was going to be rubbish but I really enjoyed it. It is probably the first film that i can say was better than the actual book. The only fault I have with... MORE
31 January 2008 11:23
ps i love you - claire-bear
legendatry seen it twice cried so much at it....d only bad ting is d accents...........would watch it everyday x MORE
29 January 2008 17:33
P.S. I Love you - Angela
Somebody wrote that it showed Ireland as a field with farms :) well it is only field with farms:) they forgot to mention the horrible pig's smell and other cute things:D BUT I LOVED THE MOVIE, Sad,... MORE
28 January 2008 11:54
P.S I THINK ITS OK! - Joe
Went to see with my wife after discussing pro's and con's of seeing this over I AM LEGEND. She'd read the book though so she won, started ok and story sounded good but a bit too cheesy especially for... MORE
27 January 2008 19:39
exceptionally fantastic - jess roo
this is a fab film. ive seen it twicw and i cried, laughed and enjoyed this film so much i would definitly see it a third time. MORE
26 January 2008 12:31
I can't believe it's supposed to be a comedy! - Fluffy Huny
This movie was 'watchable' but how on earth do they think it's a comedy? There's nothing funny about her husband dying and leaving her notes so that she doesn't feel too lonely. There's very few... MORE
26 January 2008 12:04
good story - ann
great story but the accents were bad.cathy bates is brilliant as always MORE
25 January 2008 14:07
great movie - edel
i taught the film was very good although not quit as good as the book but i would could go back to see it again, the actors were well matched with the carcathers, gerard bulter was great in the... MORE
24 January 2008 22:44
p.s i love you - swalsh
after reading reviews thought it was gonna be bad but was really good gerrys accent is a bit cat but went to see it with the girls was great girly film. sexy cast 2 MORE
24 January 2008 16:39
PS its awful - shellbell
Ps I Love You is by far the worst movie I have ever seen. Was so angry I spent €9 to go see it. The accents are appaling and it is nothing like the book. Hilary Swank is awful in it as is the... MORE
24 January 2008 12:55
fantastic.. - Aimee
it was the best film i have ever seen.. i cried the whole way through it lik..it was just brill.. and it was sooo cute,, gerry(gerard bulter) was just sexual!!! ;) i love him... yum... MORE
22 January 2008 14:44
p.s. i love you - emer
i went to see ps i love you a week ago and ithought it was brilliant!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!william and gerry are fine things!!!!!!!!!!1 MORE
21 January 2008 10:52
A Classic movie - Oh I'm in love with this film
This is definately gonna be one of those classics.....a movie that you'll never get sick of watching...one that will always find your tears!! Oh you have to see this movie! And better... MORE
20 January 2008 14:08
Awww! So sweet - Wolv
This is such a sweet Chick Flick! I totally loved it and so did my younger son (12) so it is well worth it! MORE
19 January 2008 18:32
Unmissable! - P S What a film!
Amazing! Such a great film! Made me laugh and cry! Tho dnt think my other half will agree with me! It is more of a chick flip but reali worth while going to see on a girly nite out! MORE
19 January 2008 02:04
A great movie to be viewed with one u love, A great movie to be viewed with one u love - J O B, J O B
I watched it coming from that same situtation some years ago lost my wife at 24 2 years married. Great movie would love to have had a litter a month to help me cope.What is true and sums it up for... MORE
19 January 2008 00:35
Nat - Nat
Great Film! It made me laugh, cry and want to go and see it again! A fab cast! Gerard Butler is hot! I just wished the whole Film was made in Ireland, true to the book! MORE
18 January 2008 15:06
PS Heart rencher - Julies
I read the book and I couldnt get into it, but the film on the other hand was brillant, i cried from the minute she got the first letter till the end absalute tear jerker, Geard butlers accent did... MORE
18 January 2008 14:30
Best film ever - xxaliciaxx
i absolutely loved this film its amazing and its definitely worth going to see xxx MORE
18 January 2008 12:56
I am a guy - get me out of here - JayG
I went to see this flick with my lady. I wasn't dragged kickeing and screaming beacuse I'd watch anything and generally find romantic comedies enjoyable (especially ones with Hugh Grant). Anyway, to... MORE
18 January 2008 12:53
It's only a film!! - Linda Wicklow
First of all, Why are men reviewing this film its supose to be a girly film!!! As with the accent thing giv them a break, what wud it be like if the Irish tried to immitate an American?? I think it's... MORE
18 January 2008 11:04
I Love it - signalssalem
Made me laugh, made me cry, what more can i ask from a film. Loved it totally. MORE
17 January 2008 23:06
PS i hate it - movie_goer
Gerard Butlers accent made me wince the whole way through, do not recommend unless ur not irish and dont realise how awful his accent is MORE
17 January 2008 16:27
Brilliant - Rufus
Went 2 see it last nite was the best ever i have seen in along time, but would have 2 say the accent's were really bad MORE
17 January 2008 10:46
P.S I love You - Orla
One of the worst films I have ever had to sit through! AND I'm a GIRL. i loved Cecilia Ahern's book but the film was nothing like it. The accents were embarassing and as ususal Ireland was portrayed... MORE
17 January 2008 09:02
P.S. This One's A Keeper - Lily's Mama
Due to the amount of rom-com drivel that's hit our screens in the past few years, I was fixed on definitely not attending P.S. I Love You, which I imagined was going to be of the same syrupy ilk.... MORE
16 January 2008 17:19
Great movie; not as good as the book but when are they ever - P S I love you
I wasn't going to watch this movie. I read and LOVED the book, and was afraid the movie would ruin it. The movie really isn't as good as the book, as I knew it wouldn't be! but its still very good. I... MORE
16 January 2008 16:36
P.S. I Kill You - Zed's Dead
Never..... EVER go watch this sh1te. Its makes the sisterhood of the travelling pants look like the godfather. I felt like dumping my girlfriend for making me sit through it, and to make things... MORE
14 January 2008 21:11
ps i love you - weelorie95
it was the best movie of the year i could watch it over and over again its agreat romantic comedy definitly a must see MORE
14 January 2008 17:16
PS I Hate You - Jeb
Worst film I have seen in a long time - wanted to gauge out my eyeballs & stick them in my ears MORE
14 January 2008 14:24
ok - tommytop
went to see this with girlfriend she gave it 5 stars but from male side i give it 3 worth watching and keeping her quite MORE
13 January 2008 22:32
Surprisingly P.S I Love You was not very good - coolgal
Does anyone else think nomatter where you see Lisa Kutrow she will always remind you of Phoebe in Friends?P.S I Love you was surprisingly not very good.It sees new-yourker Holly [Hillary Swank]... MORE
12 January 2008 16:25
bad accent ..... - reereex
thought the film was ok but the irish accent killed it totally and the things that were said irish people dont say it so i think it was only ok i have seen better but the notebook is on top no one... MORE
12 January 2008 13:46
PS: I love you - oliviak83
Not as good as the book but still a good light hearted film to watch. MORE
11 January 2008 12:20
good but could have been great! - jillybean2005
Well i read the book and its fantastic. So thats maybe the reason the film didn't live up to my expectations. Storyline is great but the acting was lacking. Hilary swank was quite good even though at... MORE
11 January 2008 00:41
oh dear god! - d_hill_irl
Terrible, terrible, terrible film! the idea of letters from beyond the grave could have been really interesting but it just went on and on never went anywhere, don't do it! MORE
10 January 2008 20:09
=Rubbish=Keep your money - Duffer2007
What the hell were they thinking spending any money at all in creating what seems to be a pretty pathetic storyline. This has to be the worst and most meaningless film ive ever seen... and i have... MORE
10 January 2008 16:19
very good - cybergirl
I loved this film. I like any film with a good story line. It didnt have musch of the book plot left but it worked for me. I really enjoy a film that has a bit of everything. Def a Must see MORE
09 January 2008 12:51
Just about Watchable - Clars
I'm not usually into chick flicks, but read the book which wasn't too bad so decided to risk the film. Apart from the broad concept, there's not much left from the original storyline. It's a pity... MORE
08 January 2008 10:41
If there is a Hell, Then it is to watch this Over and Over and Over and Over and etc etc - richeyc2000
Based on the bestselling debut novel by Cecilia Ahern, this movie, like the source material, is obviously designed with a specific target audience in mind and needs to be judged within this context.... MORE
07 January 2008 21:15
Muck... - Spoon
Disgraceful rubbish really....the script should be burnt along with thte book....probably would suit the mental age of a 2 year old...os someone who cannot read anything but fiction... MORE
07 January 2008 17:55
PS I love You - Liage
One of the worst films I have every seen in my life. The Irish accents were just brutal!!! The first 10 mins were just cringeworthy and we laughed the whole way through the last 10 mins! Dont waste... MORE
07 January 2008 15:52
What the hell?! - Orla84
Oh for God's sake. What TRIPE! I dragged my poor b/f along with me - I was dying to see it and I absolutely LOVED th book, so imagine my bitter disappointment when they completely changed it around... MORE
07 January 2008 15:41
P.S. I Love You - XOAINEOX
This movie was in one word, brilliant. It encaptures all aspects a chick flick should have. It was funny, romantic, sad and contained plenty of well presented men! Hilary Swank was a delight to watch... MORE
07 January 2008 15:32
PS I love you - mollyo@campus.ie
Overall film was surprisingly good. the book is pure tripe, worked better onscreen than on paper. Pity about the awful accents, should have used an Irish actor. or adapted it so Gerard Butler... MORE
07 January 2008 10:53
Lora - LauraJane
I thought this film was one of the best ive seen since the Notebook, and thats a tough film to beat. I laughed and cryed which is always good in a tear jearker. I did enjoy the book a bit better but... MORE
07 January 2008 09:45
A good surprise, romantic and funny ! - iris
This movie was a nice surprise, I didn't know what the story was about before watching, just decided to go based on the poster and a convenient showing time... and I loved it ! Time well spent for a... MORE
06 January 2008 21:50
PS I Love You x - Jan
Myself & my Beau went to see the film lastnight, i was soo lovely i cried most of the way through !!! the only negitive thing i have to comment on are the BAD Irish accents we could have had ur... MORE
05 January 2008 23:36
im a guy - bunsen
went with d girlfriend to see this, was highly skeptical but agreed to go to avoid any agro! for what its meant to be, a romantic chick flick film, i thought it was good, bit to long drawn out, and... MORE
05 January 2008 23:13
O MY GOD - SARAH6568
THIS IS THE BEST FILM IVE SEEN ALL YEAR. DEFO JUS FOR THE GIRLS, IT WUD BRING A TEAR EVEN TO THE HARDEST OF EYES... MORE
05 January 2008 14:28
bad as it gets - cons 1996
i did not watch the movie or read the book but it sounds crap ps ihate you
MORE
03 January 2008 17:10
Brillant Film-Pls don't jugde by the Terrible Irish accent!!! - Carolann_clrk@hotmail.com
I though this was one of the best films I have seen in a long time. I cried, I Laughed and I though it was just brilliant. I can't wait for it to come out on dvd. It is a chick flick but a very good... MORE
03 January 2008 15:56
P.S I Love You - Carol
i thought this film was one of d best films of 2007/2008 it was sad, romantic and funny. even tho there were some changes made from the book i still think the movie is worth watchin but d book should... MORE
03 January 2008 00:33
First half very good, but then turns all Hollywoody - Amanda
This film is good, Hilary Swank is excellent actress in it, and the story is a beautiful sad and happy story. The male actors accent is a bit all over the place, very leprachaunish, but apart... MORE
30 December 2007 12:33
Oh My God - John Stuart Mill
One strictly for the girls. Any man who enjoys this unadulterated pap is not worthy of the name. MORE
30 December 2007 12:16
Better than You think - jennith
This realy is a tear Jerker for all people out there this film is for all romantics and there will not be a dry eye in the house as we follow Hilary Swank on her journey given to her by her dead... MORE
28 December 2007 12:41
The best piece of romance to hit our screens since The Notebook - E.Humphreys
The best piece of romance to hit our screens since The Notebook.. Swank and her stunning looks matched perfectly within the timeline. Thankfully Butlers accent paled into insignificance after 10 mins... MORE
28 December 2007 11:25
brilliant!! - sunny j
oh my goodness, Gerard Butler is, words cant describe this man, leaving out the meh irish accent, he's soo yum, actually the 2 irish guys that were in it were yum. great storytelling in this. a... MORE
27 December 2007 21:49
PS i love you - CarmelBehan
i brought my sister with me to see this and i thought i was going to run out after the first few seconds of gerrys painful accent... however i did get a bit side tracked by all the hot men/bods in... MORE
27 December 2007 13:25
P.S I l Love you - Kim Rice
The most emotional film I've ever seen, I found it hard not to put myself in the shoes of Holly. A must see for all romantics.
MORE
24 December 2007 09:19
Seriously !?! - slydon13@aol.com
One bad Irish accent and it killed it for me. Not quite Tom Cruise but almost. If her lost love was not going to be and Irish actor couldn't they have just changed the script a tad... MORE
24 December 2007 00:16
Cliche ridden tripe - Mick, Dubin
I went to see P.S I love you last nite with my girlfriend. Her own advice is if you have read the book avoid the movie as they change the movie competely to suit the american audience. My own advice... MORE
22 December 2007 12:36
P.S I LOVE YOU - lisacasey25@yahoo.co.uk
I saw P.S. I LOVE YOU last night in the cinema. I have to say it is a great Chic Flick. Myself and my friends loved it. It has a brilliant cast. I would recommend it for all girls to go and... MORE
13 December 2007 14:52
9° 
Join us on Facebook
Follow us on Twitter
