Chris O’Dowd, who will probably never not be best-known as Roy from The IT Crowd, thinks you fans are onto something with your theories.

The actor addressed some of the more interesting IT Crowd fan theories that have been posted on Reddit while backstage on James Corden’s late night talk show.

He especially channels Roy when posited the theory that his character’s ex-girlfriend Julia murdered her own parents by burning down a sea park. After all, as he says, “I guess the problem with the entire premise is who believes that there would be a fire at a sea park? That just seems unlikely.”