Have No Doubt really been around long enough to justify a Greatest Hits collection? The idea seems ridiculous - until you actually study the tracklisting and realise that, in their unobtrusive way, the Californian indie-ska group have racked up an impressive list of hit singles over the last decade ('Don't Speak', 'Just A Girl', 'Bathwater'). After years of speculation, however, singer Gwen Stefani is finally leaving to go solo - and listening to this pleasant but hardly earth-shattering compilation, it's easy to understand why. Her pouting voice is certainly a remarkable instrument, but all too often it's let down by her band's fairly pedestrian, meat and potatoes backing. And the choice of a Talk Talk cover ('It's My Life') as the obligatory bonus track suggests that by the end, No Doubt were struggling to come up with new material. A pretty good band - but if Stefani fulfils her true potential, then they may just have been the prelude to something really special.

Your Comments

No comments have been posted for this article yet. Be the first!