Jump to Navigation | Jump to Content

Foo Fighters - Echoes, Silence, Patience and Grace

 rated 2

Review Date: 08 October 2007

Foo Fighters can hardly be accused of not being happy with their success. One of the biggest rock acts in the world, the Dave Grohl-led band have sold millions of albums, regularly play to sell-out crowds all over the planet, and have two 'Best Album' Grammys on their mantelpieces. Yet perhaps somewhere, in the deepest recesses of Grohl's mind, he realised that unless they enlisted Gil Norton's production expertise once again, they would never better their second album, 1997's Norton-produced The Colour and the Shape. And perhaps that's why Norton, erstwhile knob-twiddler to Pixies and Echo and the Bunnymen, has been drafted in for their sixth studio album. Echoes, Silence, Patience and Grace possesses an uber-professional sheen, certainly; but it rarely comes close to recapturing the band's glory days. The occasions on which it does (Cheer Up Boys, Summer's End, Statues) are where Foo Fighters excel, and have always excelled – uptempo pop-rock with a heavy, yet modestly whimsical edge. Far too much of the album is formulaic, however; Grohl's penchant for quiet acoustic intros, power chord-laden middle sections and murky endings is in full swing here, with a good 70% of tracks adhering to that blueprint. There are some surprises, however - Long Road to Ruin is one of several that sound like beefed-up Springsteen tracks, Come Alive suggests that the band have been listening to Pink Floyd during their hiatus, and the instrumental Ballad of Beaconsfield displays some impressive fretwork. However, the constant shift between downbeat ballads and fist-punching rock anthems makes for a distinctly uneven album. Foo Fighters either need to stick to where their strengths lie, or make a clean break from their past; on this evidence, they do neither convincingly.

Review by Lauren Murphy :
Share |


Agree/Disagree? Write a review... win iTunes Music vouchers!

Your Reviews

read the lucky stars - lea13

the stars say enough Great work boys!

Review Published27 March 2009

Star Rating:Foo Fighters - Echoes, Silence, Patience and Grace rated 5

 

Great - aaronoconnor93

Its great And lots Of Great Songs

Review Published09 October 2007

Star Rating:Foo Fighters - Echoes, Silence, Patience and Grace rated 2.5★

 

The Foo Fighters - Echoes, Silence, Patience and Grace - Album of the year? -

How can this be possible, How can one band keep doing this in such a short space of time? Is the talent limitless, have... MORE

Review Published09 October 2007

Star Rating:

 

Post your review - have your say

    You need to be logged in to post a review. If you have an account use your details to log on. Alternately, you can create an account by entering a valid email address and a password will be sent to you.

  • (Your email address will NOT appear on the website)
  • I already have a uLike account
  • I am a new user
  • (This is the name that will appear beside your review on the website)
  • I have read the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy

Search Album Reviews

Over 2000 album reviews listed here...

Your Reviews...

Snakes got a leg has rated Wolf Parade - Expo 86  rated 4
I have heard it now! -
Before I start this, I do want to say that I mostly agree and enjoy Jenny's reviews. However, after listening to this... MOREReview published 20th August 2010

ThatGirlxXxX has rated Scouting For Girls - Everybody Wants To Be On TV  rated 2
So-so... -
I thought this album was okay. It didn't bore or excite me. There are a few songs on the album which are good and there... MOREReview published 5th July 2010

BlueCornPie has rated Green Day - 21st Century Breakdown  rated 4
Great Album! Worthwhile buy! Not at their best...but they are getting back there! -
As a die-hard fan of Green Day's first few albums (1039, Kerplunk, Dookie, Insomniac, Nimrod and Shennanigans), I was a... MOREReview published 24th August 2010

BlueCornPie has rated Arcade Fire - The Suburbs  rated 4
Great Album! -
Ever since listening to Funeral back in 2005 and then Neon Bible, I have loved and followed Arcade Fire and couldn't... MOREReview published 24th August 2010

BlueCornPie has rated Fight Like Apes - And the Mystery of the Golden Medallion  rated 5
Absolutely FAN.TAS.TIC! -
FLApes at there best(so far)!!! The music is packed full of genuine attitude, without the band having to rely on... MOREReview published 23rd August 2010

Sitemap