Jump to Navigation | Jump to Content

Arcade Fire
The Suburbs

 rated 4

Review Date: 30 July 2010

Arcade Fire's massively anticipated third may not have the obvious hits of their previous albums, but it imaginatively unites rock, folk and pop with the Canadian indie giants' usual gorgeous, sweeping production style.

Remember when Arcade Fire seemed so revolutionary? Rarely has such hype surrounded one band as when Funeral organically disseminated among the increasingly fanatic masses. Even rarer is such hype so justified. Still, such levels of exposure wear thin with even the most talented of bands, and so it's difficult to get quite as excited about the third album from the Montreal based ensemble. When you've released an album as universally loved as Funeral, it'll always be a difficult thing to equal. Neon Bible didn't quite live up to the challenge, and The Suburbs won't either, not because they're lesser works, but simply because Arcade Fire were instrumental in creating new musical trends that unfortunately now make them much less thrillingly unique than they once were.

To draw the obvious comparisons, The Suburbs is a much less grandiose affair than Neon Bible, and has only a few of the kind of ravishing anthems that earned Funeral its place at the top of many critics' "best albums of the decade" lists. If anything, Arcade Fire have adopted a simpler rock and roll vibe on The Suburbs, which contrasts strongly with the orchestral backdrops and embellishments intermittent throughout. The grizzly punk guitars and solid rhythms of 'Month of May' are symptomatic of this shift, as is 'Wasted Hours', though in a mellower acoustic manner.

Conversely, it's the ambient violin flourishes and atmospheric reverb that make 'Rococo' quietly beautiful, and the exotic Caribbean flavoured synth pop of 'Sprawl II' that make it stand out a mile from the other 15 tracks here. Saloon style piano shapes the title track, while the same instrument strikes repeated staccato chords on 'We Used To Wait'. Patience is required in places, such as the 70s folk influenced 'Suburban War', which ambles along calmly to a retro guitar but later hits its stride with battering drums and echoing backing vocals.

But, few though they may be, it's those huge, pulsating, rip-roaring anthems that make Arcade Fire shine. The driving guitars, catchy melody and gripping suspense in 'Ready To Start' will no doubt make it a live favourite, even despite the lack of a sing-along worthy chorus. They may no longer be deemed the seminal band of our time, but Arcade Fire are still well ahead of the game.

Review by Jenny Mulligan :
Share |


Agree/Disagree? Write a review... win iTunes Music vouchers!

Arcade Fire - Upcoming ShowsNEW

Dublin, The O2: 5 Dec '10, 6 Dec '10

Your Reviews

Great Album! - BlueCornPie

Ever since listening to Funeral back in 2005 and then Neon Bible, I have loved and followed Arcade Fire and couldn't... MORE

Review Published24 August 2010

Star Rating:Arcade Fire - The Suburbs rated 4

 

Post your review - have your say

    You need to be logged in to post a review. If you have an account use your details to log on. Alternately, you can create an account by entering a valid email address and a password will be sent to you.

  • (Your email address will NOT appear on the website)
  • I already have a uLike account
  • I am a new user
  • (This is the name that will appear beside your review on the website)
  • I have read the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy

Search Album Reviews

Over 2000 album reviews listed here...

Your Reviews...

BlueCornPie has rated Maroon 5 - It Won't Be Soon Before Long  rated 5
Love it!!! -
As a rule I would not purchase albums across the counter in shops or via the internet, however after enjoying Maroon... MOREReview published 25th August 2010

BlueCornPie has rated OneRepublic - Waking Up  rated 5
AMAZING ALBUM!!! -
Waking Up is the follow up to Grammy Nominated piano-rock band OneRepublic's debut album Dreaming Out Loud. It has... MOREReview published 23rd August 2010

BlueCornPie has rated Kylie Minogue - Aphrodite  rated 1
Typical Kylie! -
Well, it seems to be hopeless with Kylie these days...another album, another disappointment! Just as boring and... MOREReview published 23rd August 2010

niamh has rated Scissor Sisters - Night Work  rated 3
I Liked it -
This is the follow up to the 2006 album Ta-Dah which although sales wise did well was a dissapointment following on... MOREReview published 23rd July 2010

BlueCornPie has rated The Script - The Script  rated 3
Good album. Gets boring after a while. -
I've had this album for a while now, and at first I loved it. But now that I have had it for a while, I have to admit... MOREReview published 24th August 2010

Sitemap